Sharosh Rajasekher, Unsplash Editor’s note: This is the second of a two-part series on West Virginia’s new Higher Education Future Workforce Grant Program. The authors offer competing perspectives, and the purpose of this short series is to foster a robust debate about what state governments should (or should not) do to ensure that the next generation of Americans has the tools they need to succeed in the workplace. The initial piece can be read here.
Mark Twain’s quip that “prosperity is the best protector of principle” would struggle to survive in West Virginia. As a state and as a people, West Virginians live, struggle, and hope under endless proffers on what to do about their historic, present, and future challenges—especially when it comes to economic struggle and educational deficiencies.
The Mountain State has both the lowest percentage of college degree holders and the lowest workforce participation rate in the country. The poor workforce participation number has been mostly static as the worst in the country over the last twenty years, a steady economic and education metric during the political change of West Virginia going from cobalt blue Democrat to one of the reddest Republican states in the country over the same period. Closing the eight-point gap between West Virginia’s workforce reality and the national average would theoretically mean upwards of 60,000 new workers—more than the population of the state capital, Charleston.
The twin problems of not enough degree holders and low workforce participation offer a ready-made battleground to discuss workforce initiatives and the roles of the public and private sectors therein. But such discussions, especially as they pertain to West Virginia, need to frame the state’s economy as it is, not as it would be in a land of perfect principle and prosperity.
People ultimately judge programs by whether or not they give you bang for your buck.As currently constituted, the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA) distributes federal funds to states, which pass them through duly designated local workforce boards. WIOA-type initiatives have existed in various incarnations nationally for decades, with bipartisan support: President Reagan signed one version with a divided Congress, and President Obama signed another, again with a divided Congress.
As part of his broader plan to revive the domestic economy while fighting the Soviets abroad, Reagan explained that his version “represents genuine opportunity, not temporary balm to a liberal conscience” before going on to describe the program as “a partnership between Federal, State, and local government and the private sector.” By law, the private sector part of that partnership is a local workforce development board that has a majority of local businesses represented.
While a perfectly principled world would find a way to have a federal, state, and local government working with the private sector without a bureaucratic component, the world as it exists does need management structure. It is an imperfect system, but the idea of the local business leaders having the on-paper advantage over the government at least gives “prices beat planners” a more realistic framework. It also injects a more flexible human element into the very imperfect market of places like West Virginia. A workforce participation rate that has stagnated for twenty years is unlikely to correct itself overnight. Employer underinvestment in useful skills and meaningful training is a real-world problem that even an imperfect workforce initiative can begin to manage.
People ultimately judge programs by whether or not they give you bang for your buck. A fair criticism of workforce initiatives is that they lack attainable and sustainable metrics for success. For something like a Workforce Pell program, the process of governor approval, state board consultation, and the program clearing a 70% completion rate within 150% of normal time and a 70% placement and earnings test is reasonable enough. Some might consider that layering of oversight to be too much central planning, but the mechanisms for quality control need some structuring for funding projects in the world we actually live in.
For a state like West Virginia, some gaps are more obvious than others. Famous for the rise and fall of industries like coal production, steel, manufacturing, and other labor-intensive industrial jobs, West Virginia now has workforce and education gaps that reflect the dominant role healthcare, services, and government work have in the state economy. These sectors traditionally require higher levels of education and certification than the labor-intensive manufacturing jobs that are no more. Healthcare and social assistance-related employment now outpaces mining and logging jobs by a ratio of over seven-to-one.
In this market environment, business-majority workforce boards play a key role in the demand-occupation listings, trying to project out future needs and tally current job openings. The 2026 amendment to West Virginia’s grant rules and reorganization should have included more placement and quality standards and measurables than it currently does. Tuition capture is a fair concern, as is the risk of employers using their influence to steer funds toward their potential employees.
Those issues are fixable, and the imperfect program can be modified to better suit West Virginia’s educational and economic environment.
On the government side, an across-the-board application of the 70/70 grant accountability standard to all grant-funded and subsidized programs sets clear, deliverable standards for performance. As the Legislative Oversight Commission on Education Accountability already requires a report on the first of December each year, adding program outcomes and specifics to that report would raise visibility and improve oversight. For the private sector side, copying an employer matching scheme similar to that used by Ohio, either in funding or “clock hours for credit hours” measurables, continues the direct market influence and buy-in while guard-railing costs.
A flawed workforce program that is by its very nature a tug-of-war rope between the public and private sectors to help struggling people better themselves needs a little grace and patience. But incremental improvements, vigorous oversight, clear goals, and getting as many steps in for as many folks as possible all constitute commendable progress. The WIOA program in West Virginia—or anywhere else for that matter—isn’t perfect, and needs a lot of work. That does not mean it is not worthwhile. The market, the people who make it up, and perfection cannot be made the enemy of good when it comes to filling workforce and education gaps. Call it a principled work in progress.
Call it a principled work in progress.Andrew Donaldson is a widely published writer, editor, and media commentator. He writes commentary for West Virginia Watch, is the Managing Editor of Ordinary Times, and frequently appears on TV, radio, and media across America and the world.