Volodymyr Hryshchenko, Unsplash Essayists lamenting our leaders’ violent, war-tinged rhetoric often begin with examples. Here are two, one from a Republican and one from a Democrat. In March 2023, with a Manhattan grand jury weighing charges against him, Donald Trump wrote on Truth Social that “potential death & destruction in such a false charge” could be “catastrophic for our country.” In July 2024, Joe Biden told donors on a private call, “It’s time to put Trump in the bull’s-eye.” He said later that he meant attention should go to Trump’s record, and that using the word was a mistake.
When our leaders display such poor behavior, we cannot be surprised when our students model it. How can those of us in higher education help them learn to speak civilly across their differences?
Respectful conversation goes hand in hand with careful listening and reasoning. If one cannot reason well one cannot disagree well. Large studies find that many students leave college without having learned to reason well. And many, perhaps predictably, hold back what they think: in a 2022 survey of more than 3,400 students at eight UNC System campuses, at least one in ten students at every campus had censored themselves more than once to avoid a negative reaction.
In Academically Adrift, Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa reported that 45 percent of students showed no significant gains in critical thinking, complex reasoning, or writing after two years of college, and 36 percent showed none after four. An OECD study of more than 120,000 students found that about half of exiting students still performed at its two lowest proficiency levels. Critics question what the Collegiate Learning Assessment, used in both studies, can show, but the results agree.
I have taught philosophy for decades. These numbers match what I see.I have taught philosophy for decades. These numbers match what I see. I think I know one of the reasons; few students are taught an explicit method for finding an author’s main claim, finding the evidence or reasoning to support that claim, locating any possible objections, and deciding whether the evidence and reasoning support the conclusion. Without one, they read an essay on a controversial topic the way many adults read a political column: they scan for the author’s side, then approve or dismiss.
That habit is a root of incivility. If I cannot state my opponent’s conclusion and the reasons offered for it, I cannot disagree with the idea, and I can only become disagreeable toward the person. Critical thinking and civil discourse are one discipline. Students who learn analysis without conversation never practice it on someone who disagrees. Students who talk without a method for analysis rarely get past how they feel about each other.
The phrase “civil discourse” means different things to different people. By civil discourse, we mean listening charitably to people who disagree, reconstructing their reasons accurately, and then deciding for oneself whether the argument is sound. Nothing in this asks a student to adopt any conclusion, and in my classes I do not share mine.
Integrating Civil Discourse into the Curriculum (ICDC) is the effort my colleagues and I built to act on this. It is a four-year, $4 million project funded by the U.S. Department of Education and directed from NC State. Thinker teaches argument mapping in eight lessons. Sway pairs each student with a classmate who disagrees about a contested question, such as abortion or the federal deficit, and guides the two through a structured conversation. Afterward each student answers quiz questions about her partner’s reasons, and cannot do well without having listened.
Whether any of this works is an empirical question. My colleague, Daniel Grühn, and I are trying to answer it. To that end, we built the Critical Reasoning and Inference Test (CRIT), published this year in Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education. In preliminary data from a quasi-randomized study of NC State Honors students, about 300 who took a one-credit course built on Thinker and Sway outgained a control group of about 300 by a medium-sized margin. That result is preliminary and comes from one campus, and Honors students are not typical. I would not ask anyone to adopt the approach on that evidence alone.
ICDC is designed to supply better evidence to colleges and universities nationwide. It will engage 125 campuses, about 375 faculty fellows, and roughly 70,000 students, with CRIT given before and after. If the results are weak, we will say so. If they are strong, campuses will have a course that costs little (Sway is free and Thinker costs $25 per student), can be taught by faculty outside philosophy, and comes with its own measurement.
North Carolina is the first test. Through the UNC System’s Common Ground Collaborative, with Geoffrey Sayre-McCord of UNC-Chapel Hill as co-PI, we recruited a faculty fellow on each of the System’s seventeen campuses. Integrating Civil Discourse into the Curriculum-North Carolina (ICDC-NC) makes the UNC System the first state system in the country to pilot this curriculum.
Students do not pick up reasoning by osmosis.The Martin Center’s Blueprint for Reform: Civil Discourse, released in April, urges universities to create programs dedicated to civil discourse. I agree, with one addition. The Blueprint does not say how a campus would know whether such programs work. A program should be able to show that its students improved, and ours is built to. I used to believe that if I cared about my students and let them see that concern, they would learn to think on their own. The national studies and our Honors data changed my mind. Students do not pick up reasoning by osmosis. Their institutions must teach it explicitly, methodically, and check whether the teaching worked. Students who can state their opponent’s reasons fairly have better ways of disagreeing than maximum warfare.
Faculty in North Carolina and elsewhere can take part. Applications for the ICDC Faculty Fellowship attend a workshop at UNC-Chapel Hill from June 14 to 17, 2027, and receive a $1,000 travel stipend. Deadline: Feb. 1, 2027. We invite all faculty to apply.
Gary Comstock is Alumni Distinguished Undergraduate Professor of Philosophy at NC State University and director of ICDC.