Omer Nezih Gerek, Unsplash

Grand Canyon University Bets on a Different Kind of Lawyer

Grand Canyon University wants to produce practice-ready Christian lawyers who can think, argue, and exercise judgment in the age of AI.

In recent years, a number of law schools have closed, and the rising use of artificial intelligence in the legal profession has many people saying that the demand for lawyers is certain to decline. Nevertheless, Grand Canyon University has announced the creation of a new law school on its Phoenix, Arizona, campus. Approval of its Juris Doctor program is pending from the university’s accreditor, the Higher Learning Commission.

The school’s first dean is James Williams, and I interviewed him via email.

Question 1: Please tell us about your background.

I love building things from ideation to reality, and then to success. That entrepreneurial spirit has shaped both my legal career and my passion for legal education. Before attending law school I spent six years building and operating an upscale photography business in Dallas servicing many of the same types of professionals and business owner clientele I would eventually serve as a lawyer here in Phoenix.

As a creative (musician and photographer) who also loves technology and systems, I started law school thinking I might practice in the area of intellectual property. But a life-changing tryout for Baylor Law’s competition mock trial team quickly revealed a strong leaning and giftedness in that area. We ended up winning a national championship later that year (2007), an experience that helped define the direction of my career.

Upon graduation, I started at the law firm in Phoenix at which I still practice. I was mentored by two exceptional trial attorneys and found myself second chair in a federal jury trial just a couple of weeks after receiving my bar number and in three jury trials in as many years. In my leadership role at the firm, I recruited and mentored young attorneys and experienced laterals into the firm.

There is tremendous satisfaction in building something meaningful, but even greater fulfillment in helping people discover and develop their God-given potential.

My passion for developing young lawyers eventually led me to Arizona State University’s law school, where I helped rebuild its competition mock trial team. We transformed a struggling program into a nationally competitive team that regularly succeeded against some of the country’s top-ranked trial advocacy programs.

Those experiences reinforced something I have believed throughout my career: There is tremendous satisfaction in building something meaningful, but even greater fulfillment in helping people discover and develop their God-given potential. That is what excites me most about the opportunity to help build Grand Canyon University’s College of Law.

Question 2: In recent years, several law schools have closed, and we hear that with the rise of artificial intelligence, the demand for living lawyers is going to decline. So why open a new law school?

Business as usual is not an option for law schools, lawyers, or law firms. We are indeed facing an existential question: why are lawyers truly needed? That is a question GCU Law is uniquely positioned to answer. Our country needs more Christian lawyers who know how to handle themselves fearlessly in a courtroom, transaction, or negotiation, but who also understand, as God told Abraham, that they are blessed in order to be a blessing.

We need lawyers who understand the philosophical foundations of law and their relationship to Christian faith, natural law, and the Western legal tradition and the role of faith and conscience in legal practice. This will be a required course in the first semester at GCU Law.

We will also focus legal education on graduating exceptional practitioners, not merely legal thinkers. A lawyer must be far more than merely a receptacle and dispenser of legal information. AI makes legal information far more accessible than before. Where a lawyer truly distinguishes himself is in his judgment, creativity, human-to-human connection with the client, courage, and moral compass.

Artificial intelligence will continue to get better at processing legal information in a flash (and with attractive headers). But its “intelligence” is ultimately artificial… and its judgment, non-existent. We must develop the lawyer’s legal reasoning, judgment, instincts, moral character, creativity, critical thinking, personal development, and commitment to serving his or her clients and community.

For this reason, GCU Law intends to preclude use of AI for the first half (three semesters) of law students’ education to ensure these essential skills and qualities are developed through traditional Socratic learning and wrestling with understanding the legal principles that underpin a lawyer’s analysis.

But in the second half (and prior to their summer clerkships before their 3L year), we plan to utilize qualified AI experts to train law students in the use, implementation, design, and proper bounding and verification of tasks assisted by AI.

The changing legal landscape demands lawyers who can stand up in court and persuade, whether representing a corporate client, serving as a public defender for an indigent criminal defendant, or standing against the curtailment of a person’s civil liberties. It demands lawyers who can manage a complex transaction, walk a client through a difficult divorce, help clients think through the family dynamics of an estate plan, and serve countless other useful purposes. These situations require far more than the ability to retrieve legal information. They demand judgment, persuasion, empathy, strategic thinking, and the courage to make difficult decisions.

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, GCU Law will also be grounded in the Christian worldview. We will imbue our students with a deep sense of self-worth, as men and women wonderfully made in the image of their Creator, and a sense of humility in knowing their role is one of service and sacrifice. That belief should shape how our graduates treat their clients, their colleagues, their opponents, and everyone they encounter.

Question 3: Most law school deans are academics with little or no actual case and courtroom experience, and that tends to come through in the school’s focus. A friend, a partner in a big law firm, once told me that he hated having to interview applicants from elite law schools because they had absorbed lots of abstruse theory but didn’t know much about the nuts and bolts of our legal system. You obviously don’t want that to be said of GCU grads. How will you choose faculty and curriculum to avoid that?

Our full-time and adjunct faculty will be carefully selected and will include more practitioners and former practitioners than many law schools. Academics and practitioners can both be gifted teachers, but an experienced practitioner naturally brings real-world experience regarding legal practice that many academics have not had the opportunity to acquire.

Practitioners who wish to devote the next chapter or a significant portion of their lives equipping and inspiring students can transform a student’s law school experience. Practitioners will also be the primary contributors to the development of our centralized curriculum, which will then be used (and continually refined) by all professors for a particular course. The curriculum will be aimed at practice readiness, bar preparedness, and the development of the analytical skills, judgment, instincts, and creativity that are the essential contributions of a skilled lawyer.

Question 4: My view has long been that law school deans do not need an accrediting agency to tell them how to run their school, but accreditation remains a necessity. Do you anticipate any difficulty in obtaining accreditation, especially since your stated philosophy is so much at odds with the “progressive” leaning of the legal establishment?

There must be room for diversity of thought regarding a law school’s methodology for educating law students. In its other programs, GCU has a tradition of innovation and incorporating more practitioners than many universities. Our stated philosophies are born of conviction — we believe law school must prepare students to practice.

Our curriculum includes a four-hour-credit Trial Advocacy course that is mandatory for all students — an experiential simulation course developing litigation and trial skills. We believe every law school graduate should be able to step into a courtroom and effectively represent a client. This is even more essential in light of the unknowns that will flow from AI and its impact upon the legal profession.

Our curriculum will also include a three-hour-credit Sector Field Placement in which the student selects one of four practice sectors (courts and judicial chambers, public sector and government, private practice, or rural and underserved communities) for an in-depth placement and a companion seminar to expose students to all four sector types through readings, reflection, and guest practitioners.

Our full-time and adjunct faculty will be carefully selected and will include more practitioners and former practitioners than many law schools.

Then we incorporate a three-hour-credit Capstone Field Placement to provide the student with substantial additional experience in the area of the student’s choice. Our goal is to help students find their calling in an area that suits their giftedness. We will also offer an elective in the business and management of law firms for students who anticipate working in firms. Accrediting requirements should not work against those convictions or an innovative approach in the education of attorneys.

George Leef is director of external relations for the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal.