Suzy Hazelwood, Unsplash For civic centers to realize their mission of examining the ideas and institutions of American society, they should seek help from an unlikely ally—sociologists.
Granted, American sociology has an image problem. The popular characterization of the discipline is a group of far-left activists playing at being professors while seeking to undermine the institutions and traditions of Western society. There is even a website dedicated to compiling quotes from professors, mainly sociologists, about the problems with the discipline. It is unsurprising, then, that the new civic centers have not included sociology among the explicit disciplines from which they are recruiting. Still, there are at least three reasons why sociologists would be an invaluable addition to American civic centers: we share a common heritage, some of the very best social commentaries on American civic life have been done by sociologists, and sociologists possess the tools to evaluate if a center is meeting its mission.
Granted, American sociology has an image problem.Common Origins and Concerns
First, and perhaps most important, is the overlap between the influences of the American founding and the founding of sociology as a discipline. The most cited secular thinker of the American founding generation was Baron de Montesquieu. Montesquieu’s most important contribution to the founding was his political theory, which held that the best check on tyrannical power came from the combination of separating government powers and organizing them into a system of checks and balances. The Federalists and Anti-Federalists both drew on Montesquieu in their writings. The Anti-Federalists adopted Montesquieu’s idea that a free society was best governed by a small republic where citizens knew their elected officials and shared a common vision of the virtuous life. In other words, they had a vision of integration in the absence of differences. The Federalists inverted this arrangement, with James Madison arguing in Federalist 10 that a large republic could also govern a free society provided no one faction became too powerful. In other words, the Federalists took differences between groups seriously but had no theory of how they might be bridged to create an integrated whole.
Montesquieu was also a key figure in the founding of sociology as a discipline. The French sociologist Emile Durkheim, a seminal figure in the discipline, considered Montesquieu one of the most important forerunners of sociology. Durkheim especially admired his comparative method and his treatment of social and political life as interrelated social facts rather than philosophical abstractions. Indeed, one can see shades of Montesquieu’s influence in Durkheim’s ideas about social solidarity. In The Division of Labor in Society, Durkheim argues that societies are held together by two different forms of solidarity: mechanical solidarity and organic solidarity. Mechanical solidarity is the solidarity based on sameness, on shared ideals and notions of the sacred. Organic solidarity is the solidarity derived from differences. Durkheim argues that a society held together by organic solidarity built consensus through interdependence resulting from specialization. This is quite similar to Federalist 11, where Hamilton argued that commercial interdependence within the new nation would bind the various states together. Durkheim, though, expands Hamilton’s thesis so that the interdependence is not merely economic, but political (different organs of government) and social (different social groups with different social functions). Studying Hamilton and the other founding thinkers is important, but civic education should also include the history of civic life, which includes the ideas and institutions of generations after the founding. Again, sociology has much to add to this discussion.
Sociological Studies of American Civic Life
The tools of sociologists, including historical and comparative research, social morphology, textual analysis, in-depth interviews, survey research, and quantitative analysis have been used to fruitfully study American civic culture before.
In May of 1831, Alexis de Tocqueville arrived in America to study the American prison system. In addition to completing their mission, Tocqueville and his traveling companion Gustave de Beaumont spent their time learning about American culture and society, that is, the civic life of this young nation. In 1835, Tocqueville published the first volume of his magnum opus, Democracy in America. In the first volume, Tocqueville provides a descriptive analysis of American political and social institutions. The second volume, published in 1840, is more a reflection on the mores that animated American civic life, especially voluntary associations. It is unsurprising, then, that both volumes are considered classics in sociology and political science.
In 1950, the American sociologist David Riesman and his co-authors, Nathan Glazer and Reuel Denney, published The Lonely Crowd, which would go on to be the best-selling sociology book of the 20th century. Riesman’s book details the evolution of “social character,” which refers to the collective identity shared by members of the same group whether the group be social classes, regions, or even nations. Riesman’s most important insight was that the American social character had radically changed from being inner-directed to being other-directed.
In an inner-directed society, parents and other authority figures inculcate values and ideas during childhood, and these values and ideas guide the child into adulthood and beyond. In an other-directed society, the influence of parents and other traditional authority figures weakens and is replaced by the peer group and mass media. For Riesman, mass media included radio, movies, and comics. Rather than teaching specific values and ideas, children are socialized to be ever-attentive to the changing whims of both the media and the peer group. The collapse of traditional sources of character development radically altered American civic life, changing not only our politics but our communities.
In 1953, the American sociologist Robert Nisbet published The Quest for Community, which examined the decline of the voluntary and civic associations that Tocqueville had seen as instrumental to American society. Nisbet’s thesis was that modern alienation stemmed from the combination of economic industrialization and political consolidation. Previously, voluntary civic associations like the family, church, and guild provided welfare, education, and security, but these functions were absorbed into the state, rendering the groups obsolete and tearing down an important barrier between the state and the American people. The result was an increasingly alienated citizenry.
In 2000, the Harvard political scientist Robert Putnam published Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. Putnam’s most important finding was that the past 50 years of American life had seen structured group activities replaced by individual entertainment and recreation. Using the structured bowling league as his central metaphor, Putnam noted that more Americans than ever were bowling, but they were not doing it as part of an organized league.
What difference does that make? Putnam, echoing Tocqueville and Nisbet, saw that group bowling leagues provided a sense of camaraderie because they were tight-knit social groups that met routinely for a structured activity. They were, therefore, also spaces where social capital could be, and was expected to be, shared and built. As the state absorbed the manifest functions performed by these small, tight-knit groups, the need for these groups and spaces declined. This has been to the detriment of American society, since the latent function of these groups was socialization, community engagement, and the transfer of social capital. Civic centers have emerged in this new status quo, one that sociologists are well-equipped to study.
Civic centers have emerged in this new status quo, one that sociologists are well-equipped to study.The Right Tools for the Job
Since 2016, forty-five civic centers have opened across the United States. While these centers each have their own mission, many of the centers drew inspiration from Arizona State University’s School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership (SCETL) mission. The founding mission statement was authored by Harvey Mansfield, the William R. Kenan Jr. Professor of Government at Harvard and a member of the board for the SCETL. Mansfield closes the mission with, “In sum, our new school looks outward to humanity and inward to America. Its ambition is to teach critical minds and to puncture complacency – and it tries to be both proud of genuine greatness and humble about human imperfection.”
This mission of looking inward and outward simultaneously requires tools designed to make such comparisons. Arguably, the best tools for such a study would be historical comparative research as well as longitudinal studies, which track participants over a period of years. Running a longitudinal comparison of civic participation would go a long way in demonstrating the impact the center has. Indeed, a longitudinal study which included a sample that went through the SCETL and another sample that did not would help answer whether civic centers are really meeting their goals. In addition, historical comparative research would help the center better understand civic formation and participation in the American past. It could also provide opportunities to compare the American case to the civic formation and participation in other countries. By making concrete comparisons using historical data, sociologists could help civic centers avoid utopian political solutions, which are often bloody.
Given the rise in the size and scope of the state, the decline in civic formation, and the sense of isolation and loneliness that has resulted from these, it is past time for a change. To better understand the conditions that bring about change and the options for change, civic centers should turn to those who specialize in the study of societies—sociologists.
John M. Kainer is associate professor and department chair of sociology at the University of the Incarnate Word in San Antonio, Texas, and an affiliated scholar with the Veritas Center for Ethics in Public Life at Franciscan University in Steubenville, Ohio.